If you've read a national headline this month, you've probably seen the words "buyer's market." The question I keep hearing is whether that's true for the Sarasota housing market. My honest answer is that it depends on what you're buying or selling. Sarasota is really three markets right now, and they're moving in different directions.
Let's look at what the data actually says.
The national picture vs. the Sarasota housing market
Nationally, the numbers lean hard toward buyers:
- Sellers outnumber buyers by a record margin. Redfin estimated 70.5% more home sellers than buyers in October, the widest gap in its records back to 2013. That was the sixth record month in a row, and 41 of the 50 largest metros qualified as buyer's markets, including Miami and Orlando (Redfin, Nov 12, 2026).
- Sales are at a 16-year low. Existing-home sales fell to a 3.75 million annual pace in October, the slowest since August 2010. Even so, the national median price rose 0.4% from a year earlier to $416,700 (NAR, Nov 12, 2026).
- Rates have eased a little. Freddie Mac's 30-year fixed averaged 7.11% on Nov 12, the fourth straight weekly decline, compared with 6.24% a year ago (Freddie Mac PMMS, Nov 12, 2026).
Fewer buyers and more listings normally means more negotiating room. But national averages blend dozens of very different markets. Here's how ours breaks down.
Market 1: Single-family homes (the heart of Sarasota's market)
This is where most of our local buyers and sellers live, and it's the segment that looks least like the national story.
The official October numbers from the Realtor Association of Sarasota and Manatee, released November 16, make that clear. In Sarasota County, 633 single-family homes sold, down 5.2% from October 2025. The median sale price rose 10.1% to $490,000, and sellers received a median 95.5% of their original list price, up from 92.4% a year earlier. Active inventory fell 14.2% to 2,824 homes, a 4.0-month supply, compared with 5.0 months a year ago. Homes went under contract in a median of 40 days, down from 61. Manatee County followed a similar pattern: 601 sales (+0.8%), a $499,000 median (+3.7%), 95.8% of original list price, a 4.1-month supply and 49 days to contract, down from 55 (RASM October 2026 market report, Nov 16, 2026).
A couple of caveats matter. RASM notes that some of the median increase reflects a shift in what sold: Sarasota County single-family sales under $400,000 fell 19.2%, while sales at $1 million or more rose 25.6% to 103 transactions. New pending sales also softened, down 12.0% in Sarasota County and 6.3% in Manatee County, and available listings increased from September to October. Compared with the tighter 3.7 to 3.9 months of single-family supply at the end of the third quarter, October is a little looser, but it is still tighter than a year ago (RASM Q3 2026 report, Oct 16, 2026).
What it means if you're buying a single-family home
Don't walk in expecting a national-headline discount. Less inventory means the well-priced homes still move. Your leverage is in the homes that have already sat. Look at days on market and price history, and negotiate on terms (inspection window, closing date, seller credits) as well as on price.
What it means if you're selling
You're not in a buyer's market, but you're not in 2021 either. October medians of 95.5% to 95.8% of original list price are reachable, and they reward pricing to the evidence from day one. I walked through what happens when they don't in House Not Selling in Sarasota? What the Data Says.
Market 2: Condos and townhomes
Condos are the busiest corner of the market and also the one closest to balance. In October, Sarasota County condo and townhome sales rose 9.3% to 269 closings, and the median sale price increased 4.8% to $325,000. Supply fell to 5.4 months from 7.5 a year earlier, and sellers received a median 93.4% of original list price, up from 89.2%. In Manatee County, sales rose 13.1% to 198, the median was $295,000 (+0.9%), and supply was 5.3 months, down from 6.3. Across both counties, condos still had more inventory and took longer to go under contract (76 days in Sarasota County, 74 in Manatee) than single-family homes (RASM, Nov 16, 2026).
What it means for condo buyers and sellers
Buyers have more room here, and they should spend it on due diligence, not just price. Ask for the association's reserve study, its insurance renewal and any planned assessments. If you're looking on Siesta Key or Longboat Key, start with my 9 questions to ask the condo board. Sellers who have those documents ready before listing remove the biggest reason condo buyers hesitate.
Market 3: Luxury homes ($1.8M and up)
This is where Sarasota stands out most. The entry price for the most expensive 10% of listings in the North Port-Sarasota-Bradenton metro reached $1,796,850 in October, up 7.7% from a year earlier. That was the second-largest gain of 43 major metros, behind only Naples. Nationally, the same threshold fell 2.3% to about $1.2 million, its 31st straight month of annual declines (Realtor.com October 2026 Luxury Report; Sarasota Magazine, Nov 11, 2026).
Luxury homes here aren't flying off the shelf, though. Top-tier listings spent a median of 118 days on market in October, 9 fewer than a year earlier (same source).
What it means on Longboat Key, Siesta Key and the bayfront
For sellers, asking prices are holding, but a four-month median timeline means you plan for a season, not a weekend. Presentation and marketing reach carry a lot of weight at this level. For buyers, time on market is your leverage. A listing at 100+ days is often open to a conversation about terms. For a recent example of how far a top-end listing can land from its ask, see Siesta Key's record sale at $8 million under ask.
So should you buy, sell or wait?
My answer isn't "now" or "wait." It's this: make the decision on your segment's numbers, not the national headline.
- Buyers: know which market you're shopping. Single-family is tighter. Condos and the top end give you more room. Refresh your preapproval and compare the full monthly payment (taxes, insurance, HOA or CDD), not just the rate. My mortgage rates breakdown shows what the recent decline means for a Sarasota payment.
- Sellers: price to the evidence in your price band and neighborhood. The Q3 2026 Sarasota market report has the bigger picture.
- Owners staying put: your equity story depends on your segment as well. Insurance is one bill that may be easing. Florida regulators reported rate decreases for more than 824,300 homeowners in October, with filings pending for about 450,000 more in November through January (Florida OIR, Oct 29, 2026).
FAQ
Is Sarasota a buyer's market right now?
It depends on the segment. Nationally, Redfin counted a record 70.5% more sellers than buyers in October 2026. Sarasota County single-family homes had a 4.0-month supply in October, down from 5.0 a year earlier, which is still relatively tight. Condos and townhomes (5.4 months in Sarasota County, 5.3 in Manatee) are closer to balance (RASM, Nov 16, 2026).
Are Sarasota home prices dropping?
Not on the official October data. The Sarasota County single-family median rose 10.1% to $490,000, and Manatee's rose 3.7% to $499,000 (RASM). RASM also notes that some of Sarasota's jump reflects a richer mix of sales, including fewer closings under $400,000 and more at $1 million or more. At the luxury end, the entry price for the top 10% of listings rose 7.7% year over year in October (Realtor.com). Individual homes can still sell below their original asking price. Sellers received a median 95.5% of original list in Sarasota County and 95.8% in Manatee.
Is the Sarasota housing market going to crash?
I don't make predictions, and nobody can promise one. What the data shows today is lower single-family inventory than a year ago, higher medians and faster time to contract in October. None of those are typical signs of a crash. Watch months of supply and the share of price reductions in your own segment.
What's the Sarasota housing market forecast for 2026?
With six weeks left in the year, the more useful question is what's happening in your price band right now. I update the numbers monthly when RASM releases them. The next scheduled release is December 16.
You're in the driver's seat. My job is to make sure you have the numbers to decide. If you'd like to see what today's market means for your home's value or your next purchase, request a free, data-based home value review or reach out.
Keith Curcio, Associate Broker | Coldwell Banker Realty
Sarasota born and raised. $75M+ in sales and 160+ transactions.
(941) 376-7683 · [email protected] · keithcurcio.com
FL License # BK3484188 · Equal Housing Opportunity
Keith Curcio is a real estate agent affiliated with Coldwell Banker Realty. This is general information, not legal, financial, or tax advice. Statistics are cited to their sources and dates; market conditions change.